Protecting What Matters Most

Personalized Insurance Solutions for Your Budget and Lifestyle.

Nobody Cares Like We Do!

Naylor Insurance Agency

Passed down from Father to daughter, Naylor Insurance has been in business since 1978, offering a wide variety of insurance services to customers in Idaho, Utah, and Arizona. We started with the goal of protecting and helping fellow farmers, but quickly grew to become an insurance solution provider to fit everybody’s needs.

Our independent insurance agency is a family owned enterprise with the number one goal of offering quality and affordable insurance services to our community as well as people in neighboring states. With over 30 years of experience and expertise, we are positive that we can help you with your insurance needs.

Protect your family by choosing the top insurance agents in town!

Naylor Insurance is dedicated to offering you and your loved ones the insurance that is most suited to your budget and lifestyle. No one knows when disaster may strike, but we are here to make sure you and your family, home and precious belongings are protected when it does. We offer many different types of insurance options including:







You will find that nobody cares like we do. Our friendly and professional insurance agents look forward to guiding you in selecting an insurance plan that will make you feel secure and prepared for all eventualities.

A young family of 5 in front of their Home

Property & Casualty

Also E&S Markets to fit your special insurance needs.

Mutual of Enumclaw Insurance
Safeco Insurance a liberty Mutual Company
Farmers Alliance
Liberty Mutual Insurance

Health Insurance

Select Health
blueCross BlueShield
Regence your health connected

Life Insurance & Retirement Planning

Allegis Advisor Group A simplicity company
Simplicity Group

Idaho Workers Compensation

sif Idaho workers compensation

For more information about our insurance coverage options or to request a free quote!

Skip to content